Two smiling corgis looking up together.

Nom Nom vs The Farmer's Dog (2026): The Farmer's Dog overall, Nom Nom for sensitive stomachs

The Farmer's Dog beats Nom Nom 9.5 to 8.7 as an all-round fresh plan, while Nom Nom is the pick for dogs with sensitive stomachs.

Good Dog List Editors

Key takeaways

  • The Farmer's Dog (9.5) is the better all-round fresh plan, and Nom Nom (8.7) is our pick for dogs with sensitive stomachs.

  • Nom Nom lists six fresh recipes, including lamb, plus scoopable Meal Clusters. The Farmer's Dog has four fresh proteins and a shelf-stable Instant Fresh line.

  • Nom Nom cooks each ingredient separately and says it runs digestibility studies on every formula. Its recipes are formulated by board-certified veterinary nutritionists within the Mars Petcare family.

  • Nom Nom keeps up to five days in the fridge once thawed, a day longer than The Farmer's Dog.

Which is better, Nom Nom or The Farmer's Dog?

Unless digestion is the main worry, start with The Farmer's Dog. It has the longer track record in fully fresh food, recipes formulated by named board-certified veterinary nutritionists, a vet portal that cites an AAFCO feeding trial, and free shipping on every plan.

Nom Nom is the one to try if your dog's digestion is the main problem. The brand builds its pitch around digestibility, offers six recipes (so you have more single-protein options to test), and gives a refund on the first order if you don't see results within 30 days. Ongoing vomiting, diarrhea, or weight loss needs a vet visit before any food switch.

Quick verdicts by need

If you're asking...

Our pick

Why

Which is better overall?

The Farmer's Dog (9.5)

Feeding-trial backing, named board-certified nutritionists, free shipping on all plans

Which is better for a sensitive stomach?

Nom Nom (8.7)

Digestion-focused formulation and six recipes to rotate through

Which has more recipes?

Nom Nom

Six fresh recipes including lamb, plus Meal Clusters

Which is better without a freezer?

The Farmer's Dog

Instant Fresh is shelf-stable; Nom Nom's lines all go in the freezer

Which keeps longer once thawed?

Nom Nom

Up to five days in the fridge vs four for The Farmer's Dog

Which has more protein?

The Farmer's Dog

Fresh beef at 39.3% protein on a dry-matter basis (third-party label data) vs 34.8% for Nom Nom Beef Mash

Six decisions, one at a time

Digestion and sensitive stomachs

Nom Nom says it cooks ingredients separately to protect nutrients and digestibility, and that it runs feeding studies on all formulas for palatability and digestibility. Its vet page names Dr. Catherine Lenox, a board-certified veterinary nutritionist. The Farmer's Dog's recipes each use a single protein source and are formulated by its own board-certified nutritionists, which also makes them workable for elimination-style switches. Edge: Nom Nom, for its focus and recipe range.

Recipes

Nom Nom lists Turkey Fare, Beef Mash, Chicken Cuisine, Pork Potluck, Turkey & Chicken Cookout, and Lamb Pilaf, plus Meal Clusters in chicken and beef that scoop straight from the freezer. The Farmer's Dog covers beef, chicken, turkey, and pork, in grain-free and grain-inclusive versions. That's two more proteins to rotate than The Farmer's Dog offers.

Storage

Both ship frozen and keep about six months in the freezer. Once thawed, Nom Nom lasts up to five days in the fridge and The Farmer's Dog up to four. Only The Farmer's Dog has a shelf-stable option: Instant Fresh, in beef and chicken, which is mixed with water and labeled for adult dogs. Edge: The Farmer's Dog.

Plans and shipping

Both brands build a plan from a short quiz about your dog. The Farmer's Dog ships free on any plan; Nom Nom ships free on qualifying meal plans and refunds the first order if you don't see results within 30 days. Edge: The Farmer's Dog, for free shipping on every plan.

Ownership and transparency

Mars Petcare agreed to buy Nom Nom in January 2022, and it now sits in Mars's Royal Canin division. The Farmer's Dog was founded in 2014. Nom Nom publishes guaranteed analysis and calories per cup on each recipe page; The Farmer's Dog keeps its Fresh-line labels behind signup, though its Instant Fresh pages publish guaranteed analysis and calories.

Quality and testing

Nom Nom says its recipes are formulated and evaluated by board-certified veterinary nutritionists, and its food is made in U.S. facilities with partners it selects. The Farmer's Dog's vet site says its food is made and tested in FDA-registered facilities and backed by an AAFCO feeding trial. A proposed class action over The Farmer's Dog's fat levels (filed April 2026, unproven) is still pending; the company calls it baseless. Edge: The Farmer's Dog, for its stated feeding trial.

The two plans compared

Feature

Nom Nom

The Farmer's Dog

Bowl Score

8.7

9.5

Our label

Best for sensitive stomachs

Best overall fresh plan

Formats

Fresh (frozen); Meal Clusters (frozen, scoopable)

Fresh (frozen); Instant Fresh (shelf-stable)

Fresh proteins

Turkey, beef, chicken, pork, lamb, and a turkey-and-chicken blend

Beef, chicken, turkey, pork

Fridge life once thawed

Up to five days

Up to four days

AAFCO

All life stages, incl. growth of large dogs

Complete and balanced; vet portal cites a feeding trial

Who formulates

Board-certified veterinary nutritionists (Mars and Royal Canin family)

On-staff board-certified veterinary nutritionists

Owner or origin

Mars Petcare (since 2022)

Founded 2014

Shipping

Free on qualifying plans, 48 states

Free on any plan, 48 states

Nutrition: dry matter and protein per calorie

Metric

Nom Nom Beef Mash

Nom Nom Chicken Cuisine

TFD Fresh Beef*

Protein (as fed)

8%

6.5%

11%

Fat (as fed)

5%

4.5%

8%

Moisture (max)

77%

77%

72%

Protein, dry matter

34.8%

28.3%

39.3%

Fat, dry matter

21.7%

19.6%

28.6%

Calories

About 1,196 kcal/kg (201 kcal per 168 g cup)

About 1,114 kcal/kg (244 kcal per 219 g cup)

Not published

Protein, grams per 1,000 kcal

66.9 g

58.3 g

Not calculable

*The Farmer's Dog shows full fresh nutrition only after its signup quiz; these come from a third-party label review. Nom Nom's kcal/kg figures are calculated from the calories and cup weights on its recipe pages.

Nom Nom's recipes are wetter and lower in calories per pound, so portions are larger by weight. On a dry-matter basis, The Farmer's Dog's fresh beef carries more protein than Beef Mash; Nom Nom is the one that publishes calories, at 66.9 g of protein per 1,000 kcal for Beef Mash.

Who each one suits

The Farmer's Dog fits if

  • You want a fully fresh plan backed by an AAFCO feeding trial

  • You'd like free shipping no matter the plan size

  • You want a shelf-stable fallback from the same brand

Nom Nom fits if

  • Your dog has a sensitive stomach and your vet has ruled out a medical cause

  • You want lamb or a wider set of recipes to rotate

  • You value a 30-day results-based refund on the first order

See our Nom Nom review and The Farmer's Dog review for full scoring, and our ranking of the best fresh dog food for sensitive stomachs for more options, including Spot & Tango's Cod + Salmon UnKibble.

FAQs

Is Nom Nom better than The Farmer's Dog?

Overall, The Farmer's Dog scores higher (9.5 vs 8.7). Nom Nom is the better pick for dogs with sensitive stomachs because of its digestion-focused formulation and wider recipe range.

Which is better for a dog with a sensitive stomach?

We rank Nom Nom first for sensitive stomachs. Switch gradually over about a week, and see your vet if vomiting or diarrhea persists or comes with weight loss, lethargy, or blood in the stool.

Who owns Nom Nom?

Mars Petcare. Mars agreed to acquire Nom Nom in January 2022, and the brand now sits within its Royal Canin division.

How much do Nom Nom and The Farmer's Dog cost?

Pricing depends on your dog's size and plan. Both brands quote after a short quiz about your dog's age, weight, and activity, so get a quote from each.