
The Farmer's Dog Review (2026): Is It Worth It?
The Farmer's Dog earns a 9.5 as our best overall fresh plan, with a named board-certified nutrition team and a stated feeding trial, though its Fresh line needs freezer space and its nutrient data isn't public.
Good Dog List Editors
The Farmer's Dog
Bowl Score: 9.5
Best overall fresh plan
Rank: 1
The Farmer's Dog at a glance
The Farmer's Dog sells gently cooked dog food in pre-portioned frozen packs, on a subscription built from a quiz about your dog. It earns a Bowl Score of 9.5 out of 10, the top score on our list, and it's our best overall fresh plan: fully cooked, single-protein recipes from a brand with a named team of board-certified veterinary nutritionists.
The Farmer's Dog | Details (as of November 2026) |
|---|---|
Bowl Score | 9.5 / 10 (ranked 1 of the 6 brands we review in full) |
Our label | Best overall fresh plan |
Best for | Owners with freezer room who want cooked, single-protein meals portioned for their dog |
Not ideal for | Small freezers and anyone who wants to read the full Fresh label before signing up |
Formats | Fresh (gently cooked, frozen packs); Instant Fresh in Beef and Chicken & Grain (dried, shelf-stable, adult dogs only) |
Storage | Fresh: freezer, thaw about 12 hours in the fridge, use within 4 days. Instant Fresh: pantry, use within 3 months of opening |
Subscription | Fresh: yes; Instant Fresh: optional (one-time or on a plan). Fresh deliveries cover roughly 1 week to 2 months of food; pause or cancel anytime online |
Our verdict on The Farmer's Dog
The Farmer's Dog does the core job of a fresh food very well. Each recipe is built around one named protein and fully cooked, and the brand names three board-certified veterinary nutritionists (DACVIM, Nutrition) on its veterinary site. Packs arrive portioned to your dog's calorie target, so feeding means thawing and squeezing.
It ranks first because it does best on the criteria we weight most: a fully fresh line, three named board-certified nutritionists, a stated AAFCO feeding trial, and a WSAVA Silver Partner sponsorship (a sponsorship of the veterinary association, which doesn't endorse its food). It isn't compact, though. The fresh line needs real freezer space, and the brand doesn't publish guaranteed analysis or calorie content for its Fresh recipes on its public pages, which makes comparison shopping harder. Instant Fresh product pages do list both. A proposed class action filed in 2026 also questions the fat content of its food; those claims are unproven, and we explain them below.
Who The Farmer's Dog is for, and who should skip it
A good fit if
You have freezer space for two weeks to two months of food and don't mind thawing a pack the night before.
You want a brand that names its board-certified nutrition team and says its recipes are backed by an AAFCO feeding trial.
Your dog does well on a single protein. Recipes are built around beef, chicken, turkey, or pork, with grain-free and oat-inclusive versions.
You'd like a shelf-stable backup for an adult dog. Instant Fresh, the brand's newer dried line, needs no freezer, and you can buy it one time or on a plan.
Skip it if
Your freezer is small. Fresh packs have to be frozen on arrival.
You want to compare guaranteed analysis and calories for the Fresh recipes before signing up. The brand shows full Fresh recipe details only after its questionnaire.
You have a puppy and want the shelf-stable option. Instant Fresh is formulated for adult maintenance only.
The Farmer's Dog plans and delivery (as of November 2026)
The Farmer's Dog builds each plan from a questionnaire about your dog, and pricing depends on your dog's size and plan. Instant Fresh is sold on thefarmersdog.com one time or on a plan, in 2 lb and 6 lb bags. Shipping is free to the 48 contiguous states. Deliveries mostly range from one week to two months of food (one brand page says three months), and you can pause, cancel, reactivate, or move up an order from your account. Since April 2026, The Farmer's Dog has also sold fresh food on Walmart.com.
The Farmer's Dog recipes and ingredients
The Farmer's Dog doesn't list its full recipes on a public page. Its site describes beef, chicken, turkey, and pork recipes, and a brand article names oat-inclusive versions (Chicken & Grain, Pork & Grain, and Beef & Grain) alongside grain-free ones. Dog Food Advisor, which reviewed the line in October 2026, lists these first five ingredients:
Recipe | First five ingredients (Dog Food Advisor) |
|---|---|
Beef | Beef, sweet potatoes, lentils, carrots, beef liver |
Turkey | Turkey, chickpeas, carrots, broccoli, spinach |
Chicken | Chicken, chicken liver, broccoli, cauliflower, brussels sprouts |
Pork | Pork, sweet potatoes, potato, green beans, cauliflower |
The brand describes its recipes as human-grade and made with USDA proteins, and its veterinary site says the food is made and tested in FDA-registered facilities. Instant Fresh (Beef, and Chicken & Grain) is the same idea in dried form: gently dried with what the brand calls Low-Heat Drying Technology, then mixed with water at mealtime.
The Farmer's Dog nutrition analysis
The brand's FAQ says each recipe is formulated by its on-staff board-certified veterinary nutritionists to meet AAFCO standards, with options for every life stage. Its veterinary site goes further and says the recipes are backed by an AAFCO feeding trial and follow WSAVA guidelines. Instant Fresh carries a narrower statement: it's formulated for maintenance of adult dogs.
Because the brand doesn't publish guaranteed analysis for its Fresh recipes, we can't show our own dry-matter calculation from a Fresh label. Instant Fresh labels are public, and we convert them with the standard method:
Dry matter (%) = 100 minus moisture %
Nutrient, dry-matter basis (%) = label % divided by dry matter %, times 100
Instant Fresh, from the brand's product pages:
Recipe | Label: protein / fat / fiber / moisture | Dry-matter protein | Dry-matter fat | kcal/kg |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Instant Fresh Beef | 29.5% / 15% / 3% / 8.5% | 32.2% | 16.4% | 3,880 |
Instant Fresh Chicken & Grain | 37% / 9.5% / 3% / 7.5% | 40.0% | 10.3% | 3,525 |
For the four Fresh recipes, Dog Food Advisor has published dry-matter estimates, which we report here as its figures:
Recipe | Dry-matter protein | Dry-matter fat | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
Beef | 39.1% | 28.1% | Dog Food Advisor |
Turkey | 33.9% | 19.6% | Dog Food Advisor |
Chicken | 44.6% | 25.0% | Dog Food Advisor |
Pork | 36.2% | 27.6% | Dog Food Advisor |
On those numbers, protein is generous, especially in the chicken recipe, and fat sits at about 25% to 28% on a dry-matter basis for three of the four (beef, chicken, and pork). That fat level is what the 2026 lawsuit focuses on. For a healthy, active dog it's within what many fresh foods offer. For a dog with a history of pancreatitis or weight gain, ask your vet which recipe to start with. If your dog's stool changes or vomiting lasts more than a day or two after switching, check in with your vet.
The Farmer's Dog quality and testing
Formulation and testing. The brand says its recipes are formulated by on-staff board-certified veterinary nutritionists, and its veterinary site says they are backed by an AAFCO feeding trial and made and tested in FDA-registered facilities.
The 2026 class action. In April 2026, a proposed class action, Trott v. The Farmer's Dog, Inc., was filed alleging the food is too high in fat for dogs' needs and that the brand's marketing is misleading. These are allegations, not findings, and the company has called the suit baseless. We'll update this review if a court rules on them.
Transparency. The Farmer's Dog is a WSAVA Silver Partner through May 2028, which is a sponsorship and not an endorsement of its food. On the WSAVA's own checklist for choosing a pet food, it does well on the expertise questions (named, board-certified nutritionists and a stated feeding trial) and less well on public nutrient data, since calories and guaranteed analysis for the Fresh recipes aren't on its public pages.
Handling. Thaw packs in the fridge, never on the counter. The brand says food should arrive below 40°F and should be thrown out after two hours at room temperature, or one hour above 90°F.
What The Farmer's Dog owners say
On Trustpilot, The Farmer's Dog had a TrustScore of 3.9 out of 5 from 1,747 reviews when we checked on November 18, 2026. Dog Food Advisor rates the fresh line 5 stars overall (4.5 for the turkey recipe). That Trustpilot score is below Spot & Tango's, Ollie's, and Nom Nom's, so it's worth reading recent reviews before you subscribe.
The Farmer's Dog vs Spot & Tango and Ollie
The Farmer's Dog | Spot & Tango | Ollie | |
|---|---|---|---|
Bowl Score | 9.5 | 9.4 | 9.1 |
Formats | Fresh (frozen) + Instant Fresh (shelf-stable, adult only) | Fresh (frozen) + UnKibble (shelf-stable, all life stages) | Fresh (frozen) + baked |
Who formulates | Named board-certified veterinary nutritionists | Vet nutritionists, per the brand | Board-certified veterinary nutritionists on consultation |
Publishes calories and guaranteed analysis | Fresh: not on public pages. Instant Fresh: yes | Yes, on each recipe page | On retail labels |
Compare | - |
Spot & Tango scores a tenth of a point lower and stands out on storage and value: its UnKibble line is shelf-stable for dogs of every age, and every recipe page lists calories and guaranteed analysis. The Farmer's Dog stays ahead on named nutrition expertise and its stated feeding trial. Our Spot & Tango review covers both of its lines in full. Ollie is the closer match if you want a frozen fresh plan with a baked food you can mix in.
How we scored The Farmer's Dog
The Bowl Score uses six weighted criteria: Nutrition & formulation 30%, Value 20%, Ingredient quality & sourcing 15%, Safety & transparency 15%, Convenience & storage 10%, and Plan flexibility 10%. The Farmer's Dog scored very well on nutrition and formulation, with named board-certified nutritionists and a stated feeding trial. It gave up points within safety and transparency, because calories and guaranteed analysis for the Fresh recipes aren't public, and on convenience and storage, because the main line needs a freezer. Its formulation marks are what keep it ahead of Spot & Tango, which scores better on value and storage. The full method is on our how we rank page.
FAQs
How much does The Farmer's Dog cost?
Pricing depends on your dog's size and plan. The Farmer's Dog quotes it after a short questionnaire about your dog, and shipping is free to the 48 contiguous states.
What is the lawsuit against The Farmer's Dog about?
A proposed class action filed in April 2026 alleges the food is too high in fat for dogs' nutritional needs and that its marketing is misleading. The company calls the suit baseless, and none of the claims has been proven in court.
Does The Farmer's Dog need a freezer?
The Fresh line does: packs are frozen on arrival and thawed in the fridge for about 12 hours before feeding. Instant Fresh is shelf-stable and sold one time or on a plan, but it's formulated for adult dogs only. Among the brands we review in full, Spot & Tango's UnKibble is a shelf-stable option formulated for all life stages.
Who formulates The Farmer's Dog recipes?
The brand says its recipes are formulated by on-staff board-certified veterinary nutritionists, and its veterinary site names Dr. Renee Streeter, Dr. Joseph Wakshlag, and Dr. Susan Wynn, all DACVIM (Nutrition).